I have spent a lot of time reflecting on what photography means to me and why I approach my own photographic projects the way I do. In some of the books I have read, I have found ideas that have helped me better understand my own work, reinforced my beliefs, and given it entirely new meaning. I wanted to put these thoughts into words, partly for myself and partly for anyone who might happen to stumble upon my website.
The books whose ideas I return to in this essay are Understanding a Photograph by John Berger, Another Way of Telling by John Berger and Jean Mohr, On Photography by Susan Sontag, The Creative Act: A Way of Being by Rick Rubin, and The War of Art by Steven Pressfield.
In the Service of the Goddess of Memory
In Berger’s essay Stories, I was particularly drawn to the story from ancient Greek mythology in which Zeus and Mnemosyne, the goddess of memory, have nine children: the Muses. The Muses of the arts, who help us express our experiences and make sense of the world, were therefore born from memory. Put the other way around, and perhaps a little more boldly, memory is the mother of all the arts.
Berger connects this idea to photography by describing how photography captures a moment in time. It does not function like memory itself, but rather takes a single moment from the flow of time and freezes it for later examination. In doing so, the photographer works directly for the goddess of memory. Therefore, the photographer has a divine responsibility and the power to decide what will be remembered of our time. The Muse of photography is thus Mnemosyne herself, the goddess of memory and mother of all the other Muses.
This idea connects with a passage in Susan Sontag’s book On Photography, where she discusses Henry Peach Robinson’s ideas, giving rise to the thought that photography is an art because it has the ability to lie. Bringing these two ideas together, the photographer exercises a kind of divine power, with the ability to use it “wrongly”, or at least for their own purposes, by lying through showing only what they choose from the flow of time.
By its very nature, a photograph always lies. It cannot show the entire flow of time, but is limited to observing what happens from a single viewpoint. On top of that, the photographer’s (technical) choices determine how that viewpoint is recorded.
By its very nature, a photograph always lies. It cannot show the entire flow of time, but is limited to observing what happens from a single viewpoint. On top of that, the photographer’s (technical) choices determine how that viewpoint is recorded. Yet despite the fact that photographs always lie, we have grown accustomed to treating them as the truth, or at least as a glimpse of it. “Pics or it didn’t happen.”
History will remember us. Photographs will decide how.
A Photograph Must Stand the Test of Time
I photograph my family, my children, their hobbies, and everyday life outside of art (or at least intentionally making art) and commissioned work. But that does not make what I do any less meaningful. I still work for the goddess of memory.
To me, a digital image is merely the equivalent of a negative, raw material for photographs that does not preserve particularly well. A large proportion of the “ordinary” photographs of our time will disappear into the digital void. A hundred years from now, hard drives will have failed, or the devices needed to read them will no longer be readily available. Photographs stored in applications such as Apple Photos or in cloud storage will be forgotten when their owners’ usernames and passwords die with them.
And yet glass plate negatives exposed in the late 19th century, or even photographs taken during my own childhood in the 1990s, can survive as prints and negatives for another hundred years. Their only threats are direct sunlight or someone deciding to throw them in the bin.
Because I remember my responsibility to Mnemosyne, I make prints of my photographs or have them printed on paper. This gives them a chance to survive far into the future. In my mind, a photographic work of art is not truly born until it has taken on a physical form rather than existing only as bits and bytes.
People may think whatever they like of my photographs, but regardless of their artistic merit, I strive to make each physical work to the highest standard I can, with longevity in mind. Acid-free papers, the most archival pigment inks available, UV-filtering glass, and sturdy, treated pine frames are all part of the finished work. Together, they protect these fragments of memory from the ravages of time.
I strive for the same longevity in my analogue darkroom process. Although, as I write this, I know that my current skills impose some limitations. Nevertheless, selenium toning, thorough washing, and careful handling give my silver gelatin prints a chance to survive for a hundred years, perhaps even two.
Show Up and Do the Work
In The War of Art, Steven Pressfield describes “Resistance” as a scheming force that stands in the way of personal growth and creative work. Some parts of the book are rather lofty for my taste, but I took away at least two core ideas.
Having read the book, I now recognise how Resistance constantly interferes with my ambitions. It casts a shadow of doubt over my work. Once I became aware of it, I found the courage to fight back against Resistance, for example by writing this very text. I also now dare to say out loud that I am a photographic artist.
The second key idea from Pressfield that I can wholeheartedly agree with is this: do your work, show up. When you do something you feel deeply passionate about, perhaps even something that gives you a sense of purpose, things have a way of falling into place. The path ahead opens up, and through fortunate coincidences you reach the outcomes you were aiming for, or occasionally something unexpected but equally rewarding.
All of this, however, requires you to put in the work, show up, and be present. The same idea could be expressed a little less dramatically in the words of an unknown golfer: “The more I practised, the luckier I got.”
Pressfield, a former Marine, would surely agree with Urho Kaleva Kekkonen (President of Finland from 1956 to 1982) and his famous quote: “All reasons that prevent you from practising are excuses.” In this context, the word practising could just as easily be replaced with making art.
In short, the message from Pressfield that resonates with me is to work regularly and diligently, and not to accept excuses that would “justify” not doing the work. This brings me, by a somewhat roundabout route, to Rick Rubin and his book The Creative Act: A Way of Being.
How My Photography Projects Take Shape and Come Together
Rubin describes four stages of making art: the seed phase, the experimentation phase, the crafting phase, and the completion phase.
He describes the seed phase roughly as follows: it is a time for collecting ideas and sources of inspiration with an open mind and without prejudice. Rubin compares initial ideas to seeds gathered from the world around us, without yet judging their relative worth.
While reading the book, I realised that this is exactly how I work. I might have a particular technique, a set of rules, or perhaps a geographical area that determines where or how I photograph. I collect fragments from the flow of time with an open mind, following the guidelines or framework I have set for myself.
In the next stage, experimentation, I test the potential of the photographs I have taken. At this point, I create a photography project on my website and put together an initial gallery, while continuing to take more photographs. I begin to pay attention to what I am actually observing through my camera. I remain open to meanings and stories as they emerge. Rather than trying to force the images or the project in a particular direction, I let the photographs guide me.
During the crafting phase, I begin making conscious choices, removing what is unnecessary and giving the work a clearer form and narrative. I refine the project with a more critical eye, eliminating photographs that I feel do not belong. Sometimes I return to the experimentation phase and take more photographs.
At other times, I do the opposite and focus only on the most essential images, stripping everything else away to find the core of the project. I then begin gathering photographs around that core to support it. By this stage, at the latest, the images also begin to take on a physical form through prints.
In the final stage, I bring the project to completion as something tangible, a finished “product”, such as an exhibition, a photobook, or even a video.
If you have read this far, you may have already gathered, at least between the lines, that individual photographs rarely mean much to me beyond being visually beautiful works in their own right. There are, of course, exceptions, and every photograph is a fragment of the flow of time and therefore important. But in my own work, meaning and photographic art itself emerge from series of images rather than individual photographs.
So when I talk about Rubin’s stages of making art, I am referring to the selection and editing of photographic series in my own practice, not necessarily the act of taking and processing an individual photograph.
The books I mentioned at the beginning helped me bring my thoughts together and better understand my own work. Berger’s and Sontag’s ideas gave my work entirely new meaning and perhaps a partial explanation for why I feel such a strong passion for photography. Pressfield and Rubin, on the other hand, helped me understand why I work the way I do.
Reading is always worthwhile. Apparently, so is writing. Now that I have written this, calling my work as photographic art no longer feels strange at all.